cruise or all inclusive resort reddit

Cruise vs. All-Inclusive Resort: Which Is the Better Deal?

If you're looking for a getaway where everything is taken care of, which vacation type -- a cruise or an all-inclusive resort -- is truly the better deal? The answer isn't black and white, but we'll break down what you get with each, so you can determine which is best for your next vacation.

On This Page

The pros and cons of cruising, the pros and cons of all-inclusive resorts, cruise vs. all-inclusive resort: which is cheaper, the bottom line.

Cruising has two main advantages over resorts. The first is the obvious one -- cruise ships move. That means on one weeklong vacation, you can visit multiple destinations without figuring out transportation logistics or packing your bags several times. It also means that ships can seek out the best weather. Cruise during hurricane season , and your ship will alter its route to get out of a storm's way; book a resort stay, and you've got nowhere to go if a hurricane is bearing down on your island.

The other is that modern-day cruise ships are packed to the gills with onboard activities . The newest ships sport rope courses, water parks, mini-golf, movie screens and rock climbing walls and crazy attractions like ziplines, bumper cars, surfing and skydiving simulators and other thrill rides.

Daily schedules are filled with wine tastings, dance classes, educational programming, trivia games and other activities. Evenings bring Vegas-style shows, Broadway musicals, comedy, magic acts and a variety of live music and dancing. Cruise ships also have dedicated youth areas with kid-specific and family-friendly programming, for tots to teens, day and night. It takes work to be bored on a cruise ship.

While cruise fares appear all-inclusive, however, that is misleading. Your cruise fare will generally cover onboard accommodations, meals in a few (but not all) onboard eateries, select nonalcoholic beverages (usually juice at breakfast and iced tea at lunch), pool use, daytime kids' programs and port stops in multiple destinations.

You will pay extra for soda, alcohol, specialty coffees, meals in specialty restaurants, gratuities and select onboard activities. And that's on top of paying for shore excursions, spa treatments, fitness classes, commemorative photos and souvenirs. (Luxury, expedition and river ships tend to have more fare inclusions… and higher prices.)

All-inclusive resorts, on the other hand, have rates that encompass much more. This means easier budgeting and no end-of-trip surprises. Head to a land-based all-inclusive, and your payment will include meals at all onsite restaurants, all drinks (soda, alcohol, coffee), beach and pool access, daytime activities like beach sports challenges, fitness classes, kids programming and nonmotorized water sports like snorkeling, kayaking and water bikes.

Some may even include scuba and snorkel trips, beach and restaurant access at sister properties, and golf outings; others may provide resort credit to "pay" for activities like zipline outings and ruins tours, or offer one free excursion per passenger.

The main benefit of this style of vacation is that it's incredibly relaxing. You can spend the entire day in the pool if you'd like -- sometimes even ordering food and drink without leaving the water. You can take out a kayak or go snorkeling if you like, but it's a lazy venture from the property, not an all-day excursion. And if you love the beach, you can head into the waves whenever you want, rather than waiting for a ship to dock.

Resorts also have more space than compact cruise ships. Standard hotel rooms will be larger than cruise cabins, and some resorts might have options for overwater bungalows or casitas for more space and more privacy. On the flip side, you might find that you're doing more walking to get from your room to the beach to the restaurant if you're at a large resort.

Evening activities tend to center around drinking and dancing, rather than shows, which can be a plus or minus depending on your taste. Kids' programming and facilities are not always as organized as on cruise ships.

And, of course, you're limited to the resort area. That means you'll likely only experience one area of one island -- or possibly never leave the resort grounds except to have dinner at a sister resort. If the weather gets bad, you're stuck.

It's hard to compare apples to apples to find out whether a cruise or all-inclusive resort is cheaper. Ted Blank, a luxury travel advisor and manager with Travel Leaders in Stillwater, MN, priced out a couple of vacation options, so we could compare.

A weeklong Royal Caribbean cruise to the Caribbean in February started at $2,050 total for two people in an inside cabin (or $2,220 for an outside cabin), including port charges. An entry-level room in the four-star Riu Palace Costa Mujeres, just north of Cancun, cost $2,950 for a couple, while a similar room at a Secrets Resort in nearby Playa Mujeres, a property Blank considers a closer match to Royal Caribbean, cost $4,644 for two.

That's roughly double for the comparable all-inclusive. However, all drinks, dining and Wi-Fi are included at the resorts, whereas cruise passengers would need to pay extra for beverage packages, internet and specialty dining, adding to the cost of the cruise.

On the upscale end, Blank priced a 10-night Caribbean cruise on Oceania (including port charges, domestic airfare and your choice of complimentary shore tours, beverage package or onboard credit) from $7,700 for two people (or $770 per night) in an outside cabin. The top-of-the-line, all-suite Grand Velas Resort with a similar focus on the culinary experience costs $6,500 per couple ($928 per night) for a weeklong stay in a non-oceanview suite. Again, the cruise is cheaper and includes airfare, but the resort will offer a larger room.

Generally, the base cruise fare will be cheaper when comparing similar vacations. The amount of extra purchases you make for tours, drinks, spa treatments and other extras will really determine whether a cruise or resort is the better deal for you.

When you do these calculations, don’t forget to include airfare. Most all-inclusive resorts are located outside the United States, making flying a necessity; however, depending on your location and how you book, you might find reasonable air deals to the big resort destinations in Mexico, the Dominican Republic and Jamaica.

Cruises, on the other hand, depart from a large selection of U.S. cities. Depending on where you live, you might be able to drive there or book a cheap flight -- saving on total vacation costs. On the other hand, airfare could be pricy if you're flying cross-country or your home airport has limited nonstop flights to your cruise homeport, which would increase your travel spend.

No one books a vacation solely on price. Determining which option is the best value depends on your priorities and spending habits. With both cruises and resort stays, you can also find ways to save.

For example, if you never spend any time in your cabin on a cruise, you can save on a cheaper outside cabin instead of shelling out for a balcony cabin or suite you won't truly appreciate. Similarly, if you just need the beach and not a lot of activity or dining choice, then you probably don't need to splurge on a more expensive resort with all sorts of amenities.

Still need help determining which option is best for you? Here are a few guidelines:

Pick the cruise if:

You want to visit multiple destinations in a week and have plenty of activities to choose from when onboard.

You don't spend a lot on extras like  shore excursions , spa treatments or  specialty dining . The base prices for cruises are typically lower than prices for resorts because the cruise lines expect you to make up the difference in onboard purchases.

You don't drink. At an all-inclusive, you will be subsidizing someone else's alcohol consumption.

You drink wine. Many resorts have limited, uninspired wine lists, says Blank. Cruise lines have more extensive options, especially for connoisseurs, even though you have to pay for a glass or bottle.

You like Broadway-style entertainment at night. Resort entertainment, when there is some, tends to be more low-key, showcasing local acts, or centered around discos and night clubs.

You like to gamble. Few all-inclusive resorts have onsite casinos.

You have trouble with mobility, and like the self-contained nature of a cruise ship versus a resort, which can be spread out across a huge property.

You want to receive excellent service. Blank says that, in general, even the most affordable cruise lines, such as Carnival, offer more consistent and friendly service than many all-inclusive resorts.

Pick the resort if:

You're looking for a truly relaxing vacation, with very little on the schedule.

You like hanging out in a bathing suit all day. Most cruise lines make you put on a cover-up to grab a buffet meal.

You want to be able to walk on the beach at sunrise or sunset ... or any time you want. With a cruise, you're restricted to hours in port; at a resort, the beach is right out your front door.

You want to eat and drink as much as possible without worrying about racking up high bills for cocktails or trying out multiple dining options.

You plan on taking advantage of water sports and other activities. If you want to spend your vacation snorkeling, kayaking and body surfing, you'll save money at the resort where these activities are included versus a cruise, which charges for these activities in port.

You're an avid golfer or scuba diver. You can book resorts that are dedicated to these activities, with included or onsite offerings. On a cruise, you will only be able to book these tours on port days.

If you're still confused about which option is the best value for you -- both in terms of price and vacation satisfaction -- reach out to a travel agent. Most agents who sell cruises also sell all-inclusive resort vacations. Getting advice from an expert who's knowledgeable about different resorts and ships, as well as picking the trip that best meets your budget and holiday preferences, might be the easiest way to get the best value for your vacation dollar.

© 1995— 2024 , The Independent Traveler, Inc.

Protect Your Trip »

Cruise vs. all-inclusive resort: which one is right for you.

Find out the pros and cons of each and see which option is right for you.

Cruise vs. All-Inclusive Resort

Getty Images

Picking your dream vacation can be tricky. Use our tips to help you plan.

If you're trying to decide whether you should book a cruise or stay at an all-inclusive resort for your next vacation, there are a lot of factors to consider. Beyond selecting a destination, you'll need to determine what type of experience you're looking for and what's included in the price of each option. After all, there's nothing worse than having a stress-free trip turn into a sticker shock surprise when you review the final bill.

To help, U.S. News compiled a list of questions to consider when comparing cruise versus all-inclusive resort vacations, along with suggested options for both.

What are your travel goals?

When deciding between an all-inclusive resort or a cruise, ask yourself the following questions:

Do I want to explore multiple destinations in one trip?

If your answer is yes, book a cruise . Cruises are a great option when you want to visit several locales in one trip, but aren't concerned with spending a lot of time in any one place. They're also perfect for getting an overview of a region, such as the Caribbean or the Mediterranean . If you want to visit off-the-beaten-path destinations instead of busier, more popular ports, consider itineraries offered by cruise lines with smaller ships that can navigate tighter waterways than larger ocean liners. For example, Windstar Cruises' small ships can visit small Greek islands ; remote Tahitian villages; Alaska's wildlife-filled Inian Islands; and sail the only navigable river in Spain, the Guadalquivir River.

Do I want to stay relax in one place?

If a relaxing land-based experience sounds more your speed, an all-inclusive resort may be a better option. You can spend your time taking advantage of luxurious resort amenities and exploring the surrounding areas. The Grand Velas Riviera Maya in Playa Del Carmen, Mexico , offers family-friendly accommodations and activities, as well as romantic oceanfront suites with plunge pools and spa bathrooms for couples. The resort also has an impressive selection of internationally inspired restaurants and indoor and outdoor bars. During the day, sign up for holistic treatments at the SE Spa by Grand Velas (for an additional fee) or enjoy complimentary water activities like kayaking and snorkeling. You can even explore ancient ruins in nearby Tulum, Mexico , on an off-property excursion.

Still, for some cruisers, the ship itself is the destination. The details of the itinerary don't matter much to them, as they plan to spend most of their time relaxing on board. Big cruise ships and/or new vessels offer seemingly endless dining and entertainment options.

What kind of atmosphere do I want?

If the shrill screams of children playing might bother you, you can easily opt for an adults-only cruise or adults-only all-inclusive resort . Of course, if you're traveling with kids, there's no shortage of kid-friendly cruise ships and all-inclusive family resorts in the Caribbean , Mexico and U.S.

What's included in the price?

Another huge variable is the price you'll pay for a cruise versus all-inclusive resort – and what exactly is covered.

Cruises: Taking a cruise can be a great value , but it's important to note that inexpensive base fares aboard large, mainstream cruise lines can often be misleading. Once you add in additional costs for taxes, fees and port charges; gratuities; stateroom upgrades; specialty dining and beverage packages; excursions; and Wi-Fi access, the total price of your voyage may end up much higher than you expected.

To avoid surprise extra fees throughout your trip, you might want to consider sailing with a luxury line like Viking Ocean Cruises . Although such cruises typically come at a higher price point, the line's fares cover all meals (including specialty dining venues), beer and wine with lunch and dinner, nonalcoholic beverages and bottled water, one shore excursion in each port, onboard Wi-Fi access and more. Also consider cruise deals, which often include last-minute incentives and kids-cruise-free promos .

Book a cruise on GoToSea , a service of U.S. News.

All-Inclusive Resorts: When it comes to all-inclusive resorts, be sure to research what's included in the nightly rate before you book. Couples-only Sandals Resorts International in the Caribbean offers some of the most inclusive resort pricing setups, with rates covering accommodations, gourmet dining at up to 16 restaurants, snacks, premium wines and liquors, stocked in-room bars, water sports, complimentary golf course greens fees (select resorts), PADI-certified scuba diving (at most properties), entertainment, Wi-Fi access, gratuities and airport transfers. Extra fees apply for spa treatments, local excursions and personalized events, like private dinners on the beach. Other resort brands may not offer such an extensive list of included perks, so be sure to check with the specific property you are interested in. And again – look for available offers when booking. Many all-inclusive resorts offer kids-stay-free promos on a regular basis.

Do you want to drive or fly to your vacation destination?

Courtesy of Sandals Resorts

Before you find yourself sipping umbrella drinks with a good book in hand, you'll have to put in the work of traveling to your destination. It goes without saying that visiting an all-inclusive resort in Mexico or the Caribbean will require an international flight, but you may also need to hop on a plane to reach your chosen cruise ship terminal. Still, many ships sail from popular ports in Florida cities – including Fort Lauderdale , Miami , Tampa and Cape Canaveral (Orlando) – and travelers outside of the Sunshine State can find sailings out of ports in California, Texas, New York and Louisiana. Depending on where you live, you may be able to save yourself a flight (and some money) by driving directly to your embarkation port.

You may also be able to book a stay at an all-inclusive resort (or a property with an all-inclusive option) without traveling too far from home. Florida offers a couple of all-inclusive properties ideal for those who don't want to leave the U.S. Consider Bungalows Key Largo, which caters to travelers 21 and older visiting the Florida Keys. In contrast, some properties across the U.S. offer special packages to create your own all-inclusive experience .

What type of accommodations do you prefer?

Cruise ship cabins can be tight, especially if you're traveling with another person (or an entire family). The good news is that there are plenty of choices when it comes to stateroom sizes and configurations, depending on the cruise line and specific ship you choose. Cabins can be as compact as 100 square feet (in the case of Norwegian Epic 's Studio staterooms) or as vast as 4,443 square feet ( Regent Seven Seas Splendor 's lavish two-bedroom Regent Suite).

If space is important to you, plan to budget for a larger cabin, or one with a veranda. The Azamara Quest 's Club Verandah Staterooms (175 square feet) are not much larger than its Interior Club Staterooms (158 square feet), but the addition of a balcony with extra seating, natural light and outdoor access makes them feel much more roomy. For even more space, consider splurging on a suite, which may also add valuable perks like complimentary specialty dining, laundry service and Wi-Fi access. Some suites are designed with families in mind, such as the Ultimate Family Suite on Royal Caribbean's Symphony of the Seas . The two-story accommodation features an indoor slide, a private game and movie room, a hot tub, ocean views and VIP experiences across the ship.

Back on land, hotel rooms and suites at all-inclusive resorts will typically be more spacious than most cruise ship accommodations, meaning you'll have more square footage to spread out. At the family-friendly all-inclusive Windjammer Landing in Castries, St. Lucia , accommodations run the gamut from 400-square-foot ocean view rooms for two to almost 1,400-square-foot, two-bedroom suites that can accommodate up to six people. The property also boasts a selection of luxury beachfront villas that measure up to 4,200 square feet.

What type of entertainment and dining options do you expect?

Courtesy of Norwegian Cruise Line

Whether you're traveling solo or with a partner and/or friends, decide whether you'd like to party on vacation (think Carnival Cruise Line ) or prefer a more quiet, intimate getaway (such as a river cruise ). Also think about the entertainment and dining options offered by each. On large cruise vessels, like Norwegian Cruise Line 's ships, you can find infinite eateries, Broadway-calibur entertainment and adults-only nightclubs that stay open into the wee hours of the morning. There are also fun-filled activities for younger travelers, like racetracks, laser tag, aqua parks, rock climbing walls and rope courses. Not all these activities will be included in your fare, so you can choose to pay as you go or purchase packages that offer unlimited access. Fitness classes, spa access and entry into adults-only lounge areas may also come with a fee, as can soft drinks and bottled water throughout the day (unless you have a beverage package).

However, smaller, more intimate ships still offer plenty of fun – albeit with fewer crowds. Cruisers can choose from several dining venues, some of which change their menus daily. For example, Azamara changes its menu every evening in the main dining room, Discoveries Restaurant. The eatery always offers classic favorites, such as shrimp cocktail and grilled New York strip steak, but it also includes nightly features, many of which are inspired by the ship's destination. Smaller ships will also typically have a few bars or lounges that host entertainment for more mature, refined audiences (think: piano players or other live music in the evenings), plus theaters that feature a different show each night. Still, you might find fun-loving passengers on the dance floor late at night and DJs spinning karaoke tunes at lounges on the ship.

All-inclusive resorts typically offer a wide range of on-site dining venues, entertainment, activities and amenities as well. For example, the gated 7,000-acre Caso de Campo Resort & Villas in La Romana, Dominican Republic, features three golf courses, an equestrian center, tennis courts, skeet and trap shooting, water sports, complimentary merengue lessons and more. Packages at the resort include accommodations, all meals and beverages and access to most (or all) of these activities.

Resorts may also feature more unique amenities than cruise ships. For example, at Caso de Campo, guests can visit Altos de Chavón. Inspired by a 16th-century Mediterranean village, this impressive replica of a medieval hamlet is home to local artisans and boutiques. There's also an archeological museum, the St. Stanislaus Church and a 5,000-seat amphitheater with panoramic views of the Chavón River and the Caribbean Sea. After dinner at one of the property's signature restaurants, you can hit the nightclubs, or, if you're lucky, catch a concert in the amphitheater. If you'd like to spend an afternoon or two outside of the property, sign up for a resort excursion (additional fees apply). Travelers can explore nearby beaches by catamaran, visit a local cigar-making factory or take an exhilarating zipline ride through the treetops.

Bottom Line

With so many variables to consider, choosing between a cruise and an all-inclusive resort can be overwhelming, but it doesn't have to be. Too often, travelers are lured by low prices and get frustrated trying to select from the many alternatives. Instead, follow the simple process summarized below.

Once you've figured out your travel goals and have decided between a cruise or an all-inclusive resort, you can narrow down your options. If you don't want to fly, check out the cruises that sail from ports in the U.S., all-inclusive resorts within driving distance, and even properties that offer package deals for meals, beverages and excursions. Also, consider the amount of entertainment and activities you or your family are interested in. If you're not traveling with kids and prefer adult-focused venues and activities, book an adults-only resort or cruise that doesn't cater to families.

If you're hoping to avoid crowds, then you might be happiest on a small ocean voyage or at an intimate property. You should also arrange to travel in the offseason. In addition to fewer people, this time of year offers some of the best-discounted cruise fares or room rates. Offseason varies depending on the destination, but it's typically between June and early September in Florida. If you're headed to a resort in Mexico, the Caribbean or the Bahamas, or if you're considering a Caribbean cruise, prices drop dramatically during hurricane season – June 1 to Nov. 30. Europe is a great option for deals from late fall into early spring. There is also a period right before Christmas and after the New Year holiday that offers a window where you can score discounted pricing before the season gets busy again.

You might also be interested in:

• The Top Cheap All-Inclusive Resorts
• The Top All-Inclusive Cruises
• First-Time Cruise Tips
• The Top Cruise Line Private Islands
• Cruise Packing List

Tags: Travel , Cruises , Hotels and Resorts , All-Inclusive Vacations

World's Best Places To Visit

• # 1 South Island, New Zealand
• # 4 Bora Bora

If you make a purchase from our site, we may earn a commission. This does not affect the quality or independence of our editorial content.

You May Also Like

Flight canceled or delayed what to do.

Amanda Norcross April 26, 2024

The Best Beach Hats

Megan Johnson and Sharael Kolberg April 26, 2024

The Best Florence Tours

John Rodwan April 25, 2024

The 9 Best Louisiana Swamp Tours of 2024

John Rodwan April 24, 2024

How Much Does a Cruise Cost?

Gwen Pratesi April 24, 2024

The Best Whale Watching in Cape Cod

Lyn Mettler April 24, 2024

Best Whale Watching Tours in Maine

Marisa Méndez April 23, 2024

The Best Wineries in Napa Valley

April 23, 2024

The Best East Coast Beaches

April 19, 2024

The Best Luggage Brands

Rachael Hood April 17, 2024

• Search Please fill out this field.
• Manage Your Subscription
• Give a Gift Subscription
• Sweepstakes
• All-Inclusive Vacations

Cruises vs. All-inclusive Resorts: Which Is Best for Your Next Vacation?

These easy-to-plan vacation options have many similarities — here’s how to decide which one is right for you.

David Sacks/Getty Images

While many people book vacations for relaxation, the process of planning them can get quite stressful, particularly if you’re booking a trip with a lot of moving parts. And that’s why many travelers turn to two very easy-to-plan types of vacations: cruises and all-inclusive resorts.

At first glance, it might not seem like a ship and a land-based property have much in common, but when you dig into a comparison, you might be surprised to find there are more similarities between the two than you think. For starters, both have rates that include accommodations, meals, and entertainment. Then there’s the fact that if you want to plan extra activities outside what’s included, there’s a concierge or guest services associate ready to help you out. And finally, there’s a cruise and an all-inclusive resort for everyone, from small ships and boutique properties to a mega-ship or expansive resort packed to the brim with onboard or on-resort activities. Plus, both types of trips can command similar nightly rates across all budgets.

So, which type of vacation should you pick? Here’s what you should consider before booking a cruise or all-inclusive resort stay.

Why You Should Pick a Cruise

Emanuele Longo/EyeEm/Getty Images

The main differentiation between cruises and all-inclusives is the fact that ships move and resorts do not. For some, that’s a huge plus — you can visit a new place every day on a cruise ship. And while getting off the ship every day might seem exhausting to others, you can always pick an itinerary that includes several leisurely days at sea, which will allow you to enjoy the ship’s amenities, whether that means plunking down on a lounger beside the pool, hitting up the spa, or trying out amenities like a water slide, go-kart track, or a skydiving simulator.

Cruises might also be ideal for travelers who don’t want to fly — many cruises depart from major U.S. cities, so if you happen to live near one with a cruise port, you can simply drive to the dock. And some cruises don’t require passports , depending on the itinerary, which benefits travelers who don’t have passports (or have accidentally let theirs expire ). All-inclusive resorts, on the other hand, are primarily located abroad in destinations like Mexico and the Caribbean , which typically require both flights and passports.

Something to consider about cruises is that only some cruise lines are truly all-inclusive. Many charge extra for alcoholic beverages, specialty dining, spa treatments, and excursions in port. You may want to factor those costs into your budget before picking a cruise, but even with the added expenses, cruising can still be an affordable option. 

Why You Should Pick an All-inclusive Resort

Mariakray/Getty Images

If you prefer to spend more time immersing yourself in a single place, an all-inclusive resort might be the better choice for you. While many all-inclusives feature locally inspired programming on property, you can always choose to leave the property to explore the destination more deeply. Of course, that will likely cost extra. And if you choose to stay on the property, you can expect your days to be filled with sunning by the beach or the pool, as most all-inclusive resorts are located in beach destinations. But all-inclusive resorts, like cruises, usually have a slew of other amenities and entertainment options, from spas to sports courts to kids' clubs to nightly performances — and they often have those amenities spread out over wider areas than cruise ships, leading them to feel a little less crowded.

On the pricing front, most all-inclusive resorts are slightly more inclusive than cruises — namely, alcoholic beverages are typically included in the rate. So whether you’re interested in having wine with dinner or a few drinks at the nightclub, an all-inclusive resort might trump a cruise. Like cruises, however, some amenities and activities may cost extra, such as the spa or motorized water sports.

One other thing to consider is the fact that there are more adults-only all-inclusive resorts than there are adults-only cruises — the only adults-only cruise lines are Virgin Voyages , Viking, and Saga. So if you’re looking for a romantic getaway, an all-inclusive resort can easily provide a kid-free environment.

Home » Cruise Tips » Cruise Vs. All-Inclusive Resort: Which is Better?

Cruise Vs. All-Inclusive Resort: Which is Better?

Cruise Vs. All-Inclusive Resort: Which is Better? We compare the pros and cons of each to help you pick the perfect vacation.

Share this post:

If you aren’t familiar with all-inclusive travel, you might assume that a cruise is like a floating resort or that a resort is just a cruise on land. While those notions aren’t actually too far off from the real thing, there’s a lot more nuance to these two vacation styles than that.

To start, what does “all-inclusive” really mean? How does the term apply to resorts versus cruise ships? Apart from considering your travel budget , which vacation style is the right one for you and your family?

We answer those questions and more by comparing the pros and cons of a cruise vs. an all-inclusive resort.

EXCLUSIVE DEALS ON YOUR NEXT CRUISE!

Are cruises really all inclusive?

Cruises are widely considered to be a great value vacation , but what does that really include? To begin with, the level of inclusivity does depend on the type of cruise you are booking. When you book most cruises, you are paying for your room on a per-person basis. This individual fare covers the cost of your accommodation. Plus, all meals in at least one or two dining venues; entertainment and activities onboard; kids clubs. And of course, access to an itinerary of destinations, with port taxes and fees bundled in.

There are generally more room categories to choose from on a cruise ship than at a resort. These include smallish rooms with a porthole window to sprawling suites with a wraparound balcony. Prices — and even inclusions — vary depending on your accommodation level.

Some cruise lines, like Virgin Voyages , include fitness classes, tips, all dining venues, and most nonalcoholic beverages in their cruise fare, regardless of room type. Many river cruise lines include wine and beer at lunch and dinner, specialty coffee at any time, as well as one included tour in each port. The essentials are part of any cruise fare — your room, your meals, some basic drinks and of course transportation. However, pay careful attention to what is not part of that fare, as well.

A business at the end of the day, many cruise lines get you onboard but also upsell you on various experiences. Perhaps drinks being the biggest differentiator between a cruise and all-inclusive resort. You must purchase a beverage package on most cruises to save on daily alcohol consumption. Otherwise, you are spending for each cocktail or cold beer a la carte.

Other standard extras on cruise lines like Norwegian Cruise Line or Royal Caribbean are shore excursions ; specialty restaurants (bundle packages are available); Wi-Fi access. Some activities like arcade games, laser tag, or a wine tasting are additional costs as well. Further, sweets shops or premium ice cream and sometimes access to an exclusive, adults-only sun deck area are extra too.

Some aspects of cruising would also carry an additional charge at a resort. For instance, spa treatments; shopping; casino play; or that vintage bottle of wine for a special occasion.

If you book with a luxury cruise line, such as Silversea, just about everything is part of your cruise fare. This includes premium spirits to butler service, gratuities , specialty restaurants, and more. However, you are understandably paying much more up front for the luxury of that inclusivity.

Are all-inclusive resorts really all inclusive?

Not every all-inclusive resort is created equal. But generally speaking, there is quite a lot included when you book a room at one of these resorts. Based on our time at Excellence Riviera Cancun, a resort in the Riviera Maya region of Mexico, I was pleasantly surprised even as a longtime cruiser.

First of all, drinks are widely included at all-inclusive resorts. If you like to wind down with a tropical drink on the beach or poolside, or have a glass of rose at lunch, it’s not a problem. Not every brand of wine or beer is always available. But I felt there was a good selection and an impressive list of creative cocktails at various bars around the resort property. This can depend on the resort brand, so if you are picky with your spirits, do a little research.

As for meals, I wasn’t sure what to expect being spoiled for choice on mega-ships. Though, Excellence resorts have various restaurants around the property. None of them require an extra fee or often even a reservation. From a steakhouse or hibachi to Indian, Spanish tapas, or Mexican, the venues spanned international cuisines. And interiors matched the mood.

However, not every restaurant is open every night. So, pay close attention to the schedule when you arrive to get to your preferred dining venue during your stay. Some are more popular than others, and the downside of not having a reservation is that you might have a long wait.

There were complimentary activities around the resort each day, like hat-making or a margarita demo. Unlike large oceangoing ships, there isn’t a ton of choice when it comes to evening activities at the resort. Each night there was a different show on the main outdoor stage. These were typically preempted by some live music and followed by a DJ dance party or karaoke session. However, we felt the offerings were varied enough for a stay of a few nights.

Obviously your resort isn’t moving, so your excursion options on the property are limited. Still, day trips to go fishing, snorkeling, or biking switch it up from simply lazing in the sun. (No judgement if that is all you want to do). Many of these excursions do cost additional, especially if you book a tour off the property to a nearby town or another city like Tulum. Although some resorts do not charge for use of nonmotorized watersports like kayaking or stand-up paddleboarding.

Similar to cruise ships, upgrading to a suite comes with its own added perks and inclusions. At the resort I visited, a suite came with access to its own private concierge, lounge, bar and restaurant, as well as a pass for one hydrotherapy session at the spa. In the spacious room, there was a Jacuzzi tub, a balcony, and a welcome amenity. If you weren’t already imbibing enough, the suite has impressive, full-size bottles of premium spirits and a fridge full of replenishable snacks and drinks.

Kids clubs are onsite only at resorts that cater to kids and families. Though, programming is not always as comprehensive as it might be on the most family-friendly cruise lines. MSC Cruises, for example, boasts a partnership with LEGO and other industry-leading programming for littles.

For those who can’t imagine disconnecting, these days the majority of all-inclusive resorts provide free Wi-Fi throughout the resort property.

Which is cheaper: a cruise or all-inclusive resort?

This is a tricky one to answer. But of course, a key factor for many in determining which vacation option to choose might be whether a cruise or an all-inclusive resort is cheaper. The entry-level price point at an all-inclusive depends on the resort. Like cruise lines, some all-inclusive resorts are cheap and cheerful to attract a fun and young crowd. Others are more oriented to couples-only romantic escapes or luxurious spa retreats. Don’t compare crackers to caviar.

While prices for both cruises and adults-only resorts are typically based on a two-person room occupancy, resort prices are a per-night cost whereas cruise prices are a per-person, per night cost. That doesn’t mean one is necessarily more than the other. Though, pay attention to this differentiation if comparing the total price of a week on a ship to a week at a resort.

For those who like to pull out all the stops and spend on vacation, resorts and cruises will be more than happy to take your money for every extra. That being said, there is less to splurge on at a land-based resort. Simply because you are stationary, and your thirst is well quenched.

An entry-level fare on a cruise line like Carnival is typically for an inside cabin (room with no window or view). Further, the price does not include drinks or tours. Part of the thrill of a cruise is that you might wake up in a different place every other day. While independent exploration is possible, some experiences require you to book a shore excursion. These are one of the expenses you will have to factor into your cruise vacation in order to compare it to a resort stay.

It’s for these reasons that on the whole, I would consider an all-inclusive resort to be a cheaper vacation option. You can choose the number of days that you stay (sometimes there is a three-night minimum), but generally you can choose to get out of town for a long weekend if you wish. Cruises offer sailings of just a few nights, but standard voyages are about a weeklong commitment.

One consideration is airfare. Depending on where you are in relation to the resort, steep flight prices might be unavoidable. On the other hand, cruise ships depart from a number of U.S. cities. So, it might be very possible to find a departure to Bermuda within driving distance of your home in Boston.

Tempting though it may be to book anything based on price alone, don’t base your special getaway only on a number figure. A travel advisor can help navigate which is the best vacation option for you — not only between a resort or cruise, but also between which type of resort and which type of cruise ship.

If you are a family, an adults-only resort or ship will obviously not work for you. If you are a couple celebrating an anniversary, it might be best to avoid very family-friendly options unless you want screaming kids interrupting your intimate dinner for two.

BOOK NOW: Get Exclusive Rates When Booking Your Cruise!

Which is better: a cruise or all-inclusive resort?

Unlike price, “better” is entirely subjective. Similar to the advice on selecting a wallet-friendly vacation, advisors can also help pick the type of vacation experience that is best for you as a traveler.

The very sober elephant in the room is if you or someone in your travel party (apart from children) don’t drink very much or at all. Given the default inclusion of alcohol in the price of an all-inclusive resort, you could be paying a huge premium on drinks that you’ll never even have. At least on most cruise lines, the decision to buy a drink package or only have one or two drinks a day is optional, as it is not part of your cruise fare. Mocktail options were virtually nonexistent during our all-inclusive resort experience; it was typically soda, juice, or water.

If your idea of the ultimate holiday is an island in the sun —napping or reading with an umbrella drink in hand — then you will easily find your bliss at an all-inclusive resort. If you like to explore new places and experience new things, the dynamic appeal of a cruise ship that travels from port to port will better satisfy that wanderlust.

While the masses might assume that all resorts or most cruises are in Mexico or the Caribbean, nothing could be farther from the truth. There is a Club Med resort in Quebec. There are cruises that sail around Japan or venture up into the Arctic Circle.

Something to consider is weather. For example, hurricane season normally affects the Caribbean from May to November. If you are staying at an immobile resort and the weather kicks up, you are likely out of luck — there is nowhere else to go. Despite viral videos online of cruise passengers braving stormy season, this is by far the exception. Advanced weather technology allows the captain and crew of cruise ships to do their very best to avoid inclement weather at all costs. Sometimes they even have the ability to skirt a storm entirely.

Service is another all-important aspect of any resort or cruise vacation. While I experienced stellar service during my time at an Excellence resort, service across all-inclusive resorts as a whole might be more inconsistent than crew who receive training across an entire cruise line’s fleet of ships. Read reviews.

“Better” is all about where you see yourself at peak vacation happiness. For some, that is pure and total relaxation. Others like to fill their days with tours of historic capitals or a thousand-and-one classes and activities.

This might sound obvious, but are you adverse to sandy beaches? Maybe don’t shack up at a resort on the beach. Are you anxious about being at sea? Consider these preferences before booking time away that you’re meant to totally enjoy.

Which is a better deal: a cruise or all inclusive?

To me, a deal is about getting the most bang for your buck. In this case, I might be biased toward cruising. Not only are you taking part in the vacation experience that is your “floating resort,” but you have the added bonus of visiting new countries or taking in the salty air of three different white-sand beaches in just one week. There is something about the blend of port days and sea days that combine to create an ideal combination. You can do as much or as little as you want.

Cruise ships have sailed far from visions of crowded buffets and a lack of sun loungers by the pool. Modern ships feature cutting-edge technology in the form of Disney first-run productions or Broadway-style stage performances. There’s also state-of-the-art waterparks; go-kart tracks; entire skating rinks at sea; multi-level spas; even restaurants helmed by Michelin-starred chefs.

The best deal is going to be the money you paid for the vacation you truly wanted. Do a little digging. With resources like this article, hopefully you are on the path to the perfect escape for you.

Which vacation do you prefer, a cruise vs. all-inclusive resort? What are your pros and cons for each type of travel? Drop us an anchor below to share your vacation experiences.

Related Posts

Cruiseline module – Remove Title

1 comment on cruise vs. all-inclusive resort: which is better, leave a reply cancel reply.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up to our newsletter!

Cruises hands down. A friend and I find 7+ day cruises – for under 100.00 a night – per cabin -not per person!! You can’t get a decent meal in a restaurant for 100.00 !!! We just came back from a 14 day No.European cruise out of Southampton for under 90.00 a night and saw 4 countries -a total amazing experience. Plus, we didn’t have to deal with any currency exchanges and was a totally stress-free vacation! We’re going to Alaska next month for about 75.00 a night (7 nte cruise) per cabin with a few perks thrown in. Cabins range from balconies to inside cabins. We don’t mind inside cabins as we’re never in the cabin -always doing something around the ship –

DB & The Princess

Welcome Aboard! We are Don and Heidi, the husband and wife travel team behind EatSleepCruise.com. We took our first cruise vacation together 13 years ago and have been hooked ever since. Follow along as we share our travel tips, cruise reviews, information on ports of call, and the latest cruise news to help you plan the ultimate cruise vacation. Are you ready to embark on your journey to “sea the world, one port at a time”?

What’s Trending

Contact Us: [email protected]

• Visit Family Vacation Critic on Facebook!
• Visit Family Vacation Critic on Twitter!
• Visit Family Vacation Critic on Instagram!
• 1 Subscribe to stay up to date!
• All-Inclusive Vacations
• Cruises for Families

Cruise vs. All inclusive Resort: Which One Is Right for Your Next Family Vacation?

Apr 12, 2019

See recent posts by Cynthia J. Drake

When you’re looking for an easy vacation that requires minimal hassle, planning and decision-making, your two best options are a cruise or all-inclusive resort .

Both of these vacations roll the cost of food, activities and entertainment into one easy price, making it easy to budget for your trip without a lot of hidden costs; they also shift the burden of planning every detail away from the de facto family vacation planner (hint: usually, it’s mom).

Both vacations offer a variety of family-focused activities exclusively for children in kids’ clubs, for parents in adults-only spaces, and for families to enjoy together. For these reasons, both cruises and all-inclusive resorts are ideal options for families.

Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of these options to help you choose which vacation is right for you and your kids.

Cruising Pros 

Unlike so many family vacations that feel like a lot of work in the end, a family cruise can actually feel restful for parents, while also providing the fun and excitement that kids desire.

For Kids:  Kids’ activities on cruises are time-honored, and they have evolved over the years to suit kids’ needs, including video games and arcades, hands-on science experiments, fun dress-up parties, superhero training and themed spaces—not to mention the increasingly bigger and better waterslides, pools, ice skating rinks and even race tracks.

For Adults: Parents can enjoy the adults-only spaces on the cruise ship, from the pool or hot tub to the nightclub, while their children are looked after in the nursery or kids’ club. Often, the best thing a parent will do on a cruise is find a lounge chair in the sun and take a nap—it’s one of those small luxuries you don’t get to enjoy very often with little ones around.

For the Whole Family: Cruises are a great way to explore multiple destinations as a family without the hassle of unpacking, repacking and transporting everyone from city to city. They also are a great option for multi-generational families, with plenty of options for all ages. The most family-friendly cruise lines schedule family-focused activities throughout the trip, like trivia, scavenger hunts and other challenges for families to enjoy together.

Some cruise lines, such as Royal Caribbean , offer My Family Time dining, allowing kids and parents to eat together for the first part of dinner, followed by the kids’ club staff whisking the kids away just as they are starting to get antsy, allowing parents to enjoy the rest of their meal in blissful peace.

Cruising Cons

Crowds: The biggest drawback of a cruise (as opposed to an all-inclusive resort or other type of vacation) is that you will generally be dealing with big crowds, particularly during the most popular times of year for family travel: school breaks, holidays and summer vacation. Most cruise ships have enough going on that they don’t seem overwhelmingly crowded at any given time, but our family has experienced long lines and at-capacity kids’ clubs during peak travel season—a bummer for the whole family.

Beverages: Another downside is that, unlike an all-inclusive resort, you will pay extra for drinks. Of course that means alcohol is extra, but also soda and juice on almost all cruise ships will cost you an extra fee. With kids, that can add a significant amount to your final tab.

All-Inclusive Resort Pros 

All-inclusive resort vacations are ideal for families in many of the same ways cruises are. Daycare is included; you typically have your choice of both casual and elegant restaurants; and even better news for parents: your drinks are included!

For Kids: At an all-inclusive resort, your kids will enjoy drop-off care at your leisure in kids’ clubs, where they’ll find a variety of options waiting for them, from crafts to game rooms and special themed nights, all organized according to their age group. Resorts often have special kids’ pool areas and playgrounds, too.

At select Club Med resorts, kids can learn new skills through offerings such as Club Med Punta Cana ‘s CREACTIVE, a program that offers kids dozens of activities inspired by Cirque du Soleil, including acrobatic bungee and trapeze.

For Adults: All-inclusive resort vacations are ideal for adults, given these beautiful beach or ski resorts provide plenty of space to stretch out and relax in a shaded cabana or sip a frosty drink poolside, followed by a specialty spa treatment or something more active, like windsurfing, paddleboarding or skiing.

For the Whole Family:  The biggest advantage of an all-inclusive resort compared to a cruise ship will be the size of your room. Resort rooms are at minimum as large as a standard hotel room (double the size of an interior cruise cabin), with villa and suite options that offer private pools, verandas and other features. These are practically unheard of on cruise ships, except for the highest price suites.

If seasickness is an issue for anyone in your party, or if the idea of just staying in one place is better, an all-inclusive resort is your best option.

All-Inclusive Resort Cons

Though it varies based on the location, resort and time of year, you will generally pay more for an all-inclusive resort versus a cruise. Though there are some all-inclusives in the United States, most are located in Mexico, the Caribbean and throughout Europe, so you will also need to factor in the cost of getting to your destination, as opposed to cruises, which leave from various U.S. ports. Also, families who crave a lot of variety may not be satisfied by staying put at a resort, where you’re usually somewhat insulated from the outside culture.

Cruise vs. All Inclusive Resort: Which One Is Right for Your Next Family Vacation?

Most parents we spoke to who had taken both types of vacations preferred cruises for the variety of offerings for families and value for the money.

“I personally prefer cruises,” says Karen Dawkins, a travel blogger for Family Travels on a Budget . “The daily change of scenery allows us to do different things each day: adventure excursions one day, history and culture another day and a relaxing beach the third. The schedule on cruise ships is a bit more structured, though with lots of freedom to do nothing, so we can plan family activities easily. And for us, dinner in the main dining room with familiar servers means we get spoiled by week’s end.”

Many parents also noted they enjoyed all-inclusive resorts for their kid-free getaways, such as special anniversary trips.

Ultimately, the cruise versus all inclusive resort decision should be based on your family’s unique needs and interests. If you can’t decide, try both to determine which one your family truly likes best! Here are a few resources to get you started:

• 11 Best All Inclusive Resorts for First Timers
• 9 All-Inclusive Resorts Where Kids Stay Free
• 5 Major Cruise Lines That Offer Short Cruises
• 4 Cruise Lines That Let Kids Sail Free

Cynthia J. Drake is a travel writer based in Austin, Texas, where she lives with her husband and two sons. Since becoming a mom, she’s been stranded at sea with her family, gotten lost in the Rocky Mountains, dealt with more than her fair share of public vomiting, and still can’t wait for the next trip. She writes regularly for AAA magazines, Austin American-Statesman, Texas Highways and Cruise Critic. Follow her on Facebook  and  Twitter .

Our team of parents and travel experts chooses each product and service we recommend. Anything you purchase through links on our site may earn us a commission.

Related Articles

18 Best All-Inclusive Mexico Resorts for Families 2021

7 All-Inclusive Family Resorts in Puerto Rico

10 Best Miami Hotels for Families

The 5 Best All-Inclusive Bahamas Resorts For Families

Your personal family vacation planning starts now.

Get expert advice, handpicked recommendations, and tips for your family all year round!

Get family travel & tips from our experts

By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use .

Thanks for signing up!

• Ask a Cruise Question

Cruise vs. All Inclusive Resort ?

By susycruise , October 19, 2007 in Ask a Cruise Question

Recommended Posts

My question is; is anyone as hooked on resorts as they are on cruising?:confused: :confused: :confused:

We have only cruised a couple of times and can't imagine a better vacation. Our good friends have done both cruising and an all inclusive and would love us to join them on the later, however my DH doesn't feel he would enjoy the land vacation as much as a cruise.

Link to comment

Share on other sites.

There are many people who would rather do an all inclusive over a cruise. They are very different vacations and just as there are cruisers who have different expectations of a cruise so too with land vacations. Its an individual preference and there is no right or wrong. For us, we have done all inclusives but cruising is our preferen ce.

I think I saw this question asked recently on this board and I saw a very astute answer. The answers you get on a cruise board will be a little biased towards cruising.

Personally, I have yet to go on a cruise, but I have done a few AIs in the Dominican Republic and I can't imagine a better sun holiday than what I have experienced there. I love swimming in the ocean and the beaches in Punta Cana are some of the best in the world.

My BF and I are booked to go on the Carnival Glory this New Year's and while I'm very excited, I am a little sad that we're not going to an AI. I am certainly going to miss the free-flowing alcohol at the swim-up bar. :) I find AIs are wonderfully relaxing, although there are generally lots of organized activities (sports and the like) to get involved in if you want and there are lots of excursions to be booked to explore the country you are in. The staff are very attentive and friendly and work hard to make your vacation the best it can be. The food is plentiful and tasty and the rooms are large and comfortable (although, as you might expect, different resorts do a little better than others in these categories).

I'm sure there are those out there that have done both that can give you a better answer, but I firmly believe that AIs are a great way to spend your vacation. :)

My opinion: I like both!

I have done both cruises and all inclusive vacations. On my last cruise in January, I found that I would LOVE to do an AI in Cabo San Lucas! It was beautiful and the people were very friendly. I'm doing another cruise this coming January, but next year is definatly and AI vacation!

I like cruising to find the spots to do the AI's.

I like the AI's to totally explore the area and do everything that's available there!

We enjoy both cruising and AI.

I think cruising is a better value for the $ than AI based on cost per night per person.

We like to think that cruising to a port is an introductory trip. If we like the port, we may return for an AI for a longer stay.

A friend of mine recently went on a 4 day AI trip to Jamaica and it rained every day. That would be a huge bummer. The biggest advantage of a cruise ship is that it can avoid storms and seek out the sunny skies!

I do both every year, and love every minute I am on the ship and on the beach. Cruising is wonderful as you get to go to so many different ports and have the glamor and tradition of sailing. AI's are geat money savers if you are drinkers and love vegging on the beach. We are leaving on the Crown in 2 weeks from SJU, but we are also staying at Dreams Tulum next June, and then a cruise in August in the Med for 12 nights.

As long as I am getting on a plane and going somewhere, I am happy! I have stayed at AI's in Mexico, Punta Cana, Jamaica, Aruba, and have stayed at many islands where there were AI's but I stayed at an EP. Aruba is one of the places where the local restaurants are FABULOUS, and it would be a crime not to eat at some of them.

If you are looking at any particular AI, just ask as I have been to most of them in the more popular locations.:D

My DH and I are now hooked on cruising, but next year, we are going to do both an AI and a cruise. It will be our first AI with a group of friends. We are going to the Barcelo Maya Beach Resort in Riviera Maya, Mexico. Anyone ever been there? Not sure what to expect, but this group has been doing AI for the last 4 years. We are beach lovers, so I'm sure we'll have a great time. Also doing a group cruise next October, but don't have it booked yet.

I've done a heck of a lot more AI's throughout the Caribbean and Mexico than the 5 cruises I've been on. As said above both are different types of vacations and both have their good and not so good points depending on your perspective. Don't skimp on the AI, stay at excellent ones only, if you can manage it. I do believe it's easier for someone from an AI background only to enjoy a cruise. A committed cruiser will most likely not enjoy the AI as much. It doesn't mean cruisers can't or won't enjoy AI's, it just means cruisers are nuts........about cruising :)

will do both every yr. only look for the best deals for quality AI... LOVE THE BEACH so weather i;m cruisin or resort if there is sun i am happy, heading for cruise 8, in march, but we love to go AI at the end of summer. yea. hurricane season... we just book a few days before we leave so we know the weather... i look for deals 5 apple and up... anywhere the sun is ... went to cancun, last wk . in aug loved it, most relaxing vac. ever.... no cruises go there so we defintly will go back... soon. you really get your money worth, food was compareable to cruise food , little better... booze free... not a drinker... when i left am now... strawberry margariti, strawberry pina colada... all day long... ... got to go leavin for flordia... siesta key today... just a week in the sun in the usa.

cruisegal40

Yes, seawyllow, we are going to have to talk on the cruise in two weeks. I have been looking into either a cruise or AI for out April vacation w/ the family. Speak w/ you then!

Do the all-inclusive at least once--he may love it! Especially if it's at a NICE resort, and not some half-rate place!

For me, warm sun, a palm tree and waiters bringing drinks are good things! I don't particularly care if its on a ship or land!

We are going on our third cruise and love them. :) Even convinced other family members to join us in the upcoming one.

Other family wants to try an AI next year.

Any suggestions for the caribbean area? Some activites, beach kinda stuff. We are kinda thinking St Thomas maybe so we could do a day trip over to some of the other islands if wanted. Can't quite decide. :rolleyes: Email if want/need.

I have done AI's but never cruised. Booked my cruise for March and plan on doing some of the day excursions to AI's.

Doing both on the same vacation. I can't lose! :D

Been to Barcelo 2x, B Tucancun, and B La Jolla Mismaloya in Puerto Vallarta, but not to B MBR. Great experiences at both Barcelos. I would check TripAdvisor, read the reviews and you will have many tips on what to do to make your trip as good as you can. Going with a group is great because you can share cabs, etc. If you can visit Tulum (ruins).

newmexicoNita

My question is; is anyone as hooked on resorts as they are on cruising?:confused: :confused: :confused: We have only cruised a couple of times and can't imagine a better vacation. Our good friends have done both cruising and an all inclusive and would love us to join them on the later, however my DH doesn't feel he would enjoy the land vacation as much as a cruise.

My DD and I will be going to the Dominican Rep. Any thoughts where to stay for AI? We will be going to visit our sponsored children in Santo Domingo. My DD has sponsored hers since she was 11 yrs. old with her allowance. She is now 23. I looked into cruises from there and thought about flying there and then cruising. Any ideas? Thanx.

Good point. I've been on land vacations where it has rained every day for the whole week. Never had more than a day of rain on a cruise, if that.

Personally I enjoy sailing on the "high seas". Laying on a beach every day for a week doesn't sound like my cup of tea. I don't even do that at home and I live only 45mins from the ocean. I WILL give an AI a try someday though.

Good point. I've been on land vacations where it has rained every day for the whole week. Never had more than a day of rain on a cruise, if that.   Personally I enjoy sailing on the "high seas". Laying on a beach every day for a week doesn't sound like my cup of tea. I don't even do that at home and I live only 45mins from the ocean. I WILL give an AI a try someday though.   Jimmers:)

Jimmers, let me know when you are travelling, having land vacations where it has rained for the entire week is NOT lucky :D I've been lucky I guess, been to over a dozen AI's in 25 years I have NEVER had rain for an entire week. In Fact the worst I've had is the daily shower around 4-5:00 pm, it lasts for about 10 - 20 minutes and then the sun is out again. :)

[quo Personally, I have yet to go on a cruise, but I have done a few AIs in the Dominican Republic and I can't imagine a better sun holiday than what I have experienced there. I love swimming in the ocean and the beaches in Punta Cana are some of the best in the world. My DD and I will be going to the Dominican Rep. Any thoughts where to stay for AI? We will be going to visit our sponsored children in Santo Domingo. My DD has sponsored hers since she was 11 yrs. old with her allowance. She is now 23. I looked into cruises from there and thought about flying there and then cruising. Any ideas? Thanx.

You are right, Punta Cana has some wonderful beaches, especially Bavaro Beach. The Riu Palace Punta Cana, the Iberostar Bavaro, and for top shelf, the Paradisus Punta Cana are my chioces. The Sunscape Punta Cana is becoming a Dreams resort, which will put it up a notch in the luxury and amenities categories, so it will be a great choice too. One unsung property that I think is a great deal is the Sunscape La Romana. Prices are always better there. You have a longer transfer time to the resort as it is the opposite way from Bavaro beach, but it is fabulous. Water is so calm there, and it is a fun family resort. If you are thinking of going there during school break times, it will be busy, but off season times, it is great and quiet. I have stayed at all of these, but I brought my family to the Ocean Blue last year. I chose this resort as it was one of the few that will take 5 in a room, and we had a group of families going. All juior suites, the largest and cleanest pools I have seen, gorgeous property, but the food was not top shelf. We did not starve, but it could have been better. DH did not like the food, but I love island food and enjoyed it. The premium restaurant on the beach had the best caribbean lobster I have ever had! If you are looking at any particular resort, just ask as I have been to almost all of them in that area :D

Any AI resorts that have pricing comparable to a cruise? The few times I have searched, the price was well over $200 a night + airfare.

Christine, we stayed at the Paradisus Punta Cana in 2004, had a great time, beautiful place, everything "top shelf". We are heading to the newer property, Paradisus Palma Real, around the end of Feb-early Mar. It looks spectacular and is a heck of a lot closer to Sol Melia's golf course. :D

It depends where you are travelling from and the availability of "package vacations". If you price them out a la carte, it will be expensive. I know for us, out of Toronto, a top notch AI is a lot less money than a cruise when everything is factored in, including the type of cabin we stay in.

Christine will know and be able to help you. You may want to check out a giant of a land vacation website, trip advisor dot com. I think they own this site now.

It depends where you are travelling from and the availability of "package vacations". If you price them out a la carte, it will be expensive. I know for us, out of Toronto, a top notch AI is a lot less money than a cruise when everything is factored in, including the type of cabin we stay in.   Christine will know and be able to help you. You may want to check out a giant of a land vacation website, trip advisor dot com. I think they own this site now.

yes, they do own CC now. As for the cost of AI, the better ones are more expensive than the basic cruise all in all. Even considering the liquor issues. If you choose an off season the prices are quite a bit lower, on the other hand if you go off season cruises are cheaper as well.

I am not discouraging anyone from doing an AI, they can be fun, very luxurious and some have great food (not all, for sure) I have clients that wouldn't do any other kind of vacation, I have more that like cruising.

It would depend on when you want to go, for how long, and how many there are of you. Any kids? Certain resorts include them for free, it would just be airfare. Air is a big determining factor, especially during holidays and vacation times. It can also matter where you are coming from. Big hubs have direct flights, charters, etc and can be less costly. Certain airports have charter services like Bradley in CT, Humphrey in Minn, etc. We are spoiled here in NJ because we can choose between JFK, LaGuardia, Newark, and Philly. Even Atlantic City can have some great deals on Spirit. Apple Vacations has their own charter airline that they use for their packages and they are now selling to the general public on flights from their cities.

BobBeaSea, good choice, I love golf too and you got some free rounds coming to you. Have you done "teeth of the dog" yet? WOW!

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

• Welcome to Cruise Critic
• ANNOUNCEMENT: Set Sail Beyond the Ordinary with Oceania Cruises
• ANNOUNCEMENT: The Widest View in the Whole Wide World
• New Cruisers
• Cruise Lines “A – O”
• Cruise Lines “P – Z”
• River Cruising
• Cruise Critic News & Features
• Digital Photography & Cruise Technology
• Special Interest Cruising
• Cruise Discussion Topics
• UK Cruising
• Australia & New Zealand Cruisers
• Canadian Cruisers
• North American Homeports
• Ports of Call
• Cruise Conversations

Announcements

• New to Cruise Critic? Join our Community!

Write Your Own Amazing Review !

Click this gorgeous photo by member SUPERstar777 to share your review!

Features & News

LauraS · Started Friday at 07:21 PM

LauraS · Started Friday at 03:17 PM

LauraS · Started Thursday at 04:15 PM

LauraS · Started Thursday at 03:00 PM

LauraS · Started Thursday at 10:41 AM

• Existing user? Sign in OR Create an Account
• Find Your Roll Call
• Meet & Mingle
• Community Help Center
• All Activity
• Member Photo Albums
• Meet & Mingle Photos
• Favorite Cruise Memories
• Cruise Food Photos
• Cruise Ship Photos
• Ports of Call Photos
• Towel Animal Photos
• Amazing, Funny & Totally Awesome Cruise Photos
• Write a Review
• Live Cruise Reports
• Member Cruise Reviews
• Create New...

Cruises vs. all inclusive resorts: why one is the clear victor…

Enjoy resort perks with cruise versatility on our luxury voyages..

Not to generalize, but if there’s one thing that’s true of most humans, it’s this: we’re lazy, and this is why we love all inclusive cruises and resorts. We want to have fun without venturing too far to have it. We want to travel the world, but dread the tedium of airplanes and airports. We love trying different cuisines, but if it means getting in the car and driving to a restaurant, we’ll probably just reheat something from the fridge. There’s certainly nothing wrong with convenience, and preferring to have amenities at our fingertips. That’s what makes an all inclusive cruise, and all inclusive resorts, so appealing to travelers. 

On vacation, you’re allowed to be lazy. You shouldn’t have to worry about navigating public transportation, or figuring out where to eat every meal. All inclusive experiences are pretty self-explanatory in their appeal – everything you need is just… included. It’s right there. Right in front of you, or a quick elevator ride away. Now, all inclusive resorts are great if you’re okay sticking to your room, the hotel pool, and onsite restaurants the entire time, but our adult only cruises give Sailors the chance to explore multiple vacation destinations on a single trip. And our always included luxury philosophy means you can be as lazy or active as you like – on our dime.  

Are cruises all inclusive?

The best part about an all inclusive experience, whether it’s a resort or on our cruise ships, is all the luxurious amenities that are included. Well, in theory anyway. Many resorts and cruises boast all inclusive luxuries , but what you really get are bare bones amenities, barely passable food, and a pool deck you have to share with hundreds of screaming kids – and the real luxury comes at a steep upcharge. Not on Virgin Voyages crusie ships. Our adults-only cruises are all about perks with no fine print . From food and WiFi to basic beverages, workout classes, and Vegas-worthy entertainment, we take our always-included luxury promise seriously. 

Food is undoubtedly one of our favorite onboard luxuries, and with 20+ eateries (all included in your cruise fare ticket ) you won’t be starved for choice. From elaborate comfort food brunches to Korean BBQ, our elevated and sustainable dining is completely covered – and yes, that includes gratuities too. When you’re not indulging in food, indulge in our free world-class entertainment, like the interactive shows in our Red Room theater, karaoke nights in The Groupie, onboard events like PJ parties, and NYC-inspired nightclub The Manor (without the NYC cover charge).   

So what separates cruising from all inclusive resorts? 

The benefits of an all inclusive experience pretty much speak for themselves, but cruises and resorts are two very, very different experiences. When it comes to choosing which one we prefer – well, we’re obviously a little biased. Adults-only all inclusive resorts may offer the same sophisticated vacation environment as our adult only cruises, but there’s one differentiating fact you simply can’t argue with: resorts stay in one place. Cruises don’t, often times traveling to multiple vacation destinations. Maybe we’re just suckers for convenience, or maybe our wanderlust is too strong to be satisfied by visiting just one destination, but what we love about cruising is its ability to bring you to multiple vacation spots on the same trip. 

The Caribbean, for example, is dotted with all inclusive resort experiences, but once you pick one, you’re pretty much confined to that island – or even the resort property – for the entirety of your vacation stay. Cruising is like taking three or four (or in some cases, ten!) vacations in one. You'll be able to visit some of the best Caribbean Islands in one vacation. Hitting multiple cruise ports means weaving in and out of various historical traditions, cuisines, natural landscapes, and excursions, without having to hop connecting flights or lug your travel luggage anywhere. So don’t pick between the Bahamas, Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic, and Mexico – visit all four, with a few sunshiny sea days sprinkled in between. It’s as simple as browsing our epic cruise itineraries or contacting one of our team members to help you book your next cruise .

Related Articles

Lock in our most inclusive offer of the year., nama-stay... on our wellness retreat at sea., “nothing short of pure quality” — the virgin voyages approach to food on board..

13 mistakes to avoid at all-inclusive resorts

I stayed for 28 nights at an all-inclusive resort in the Dominican Republic during hurricane season — pre-coronavirus times. I live out of hotels and I discovered an all-inclusive property that was bookable for just 8,000 Choice points per night. So my husband and I went and lived the all-inclusive life for nearly a month.

Between this 28-night stay and a shorter three-night stay at a different property, I discovered many mistakes that can be made when booking, packing for and staying at an all-inclusive resort. Most of the mistakes in this guide only apply to all-inclusive resorts, but some could also apply to other trips.

Here are the mistakes to avoid when traveling to an all-inclusive resort.

Assuming everything is included

"All-inclusive" might make you believe everything is included, but this is rarely the case. You may incur extra charges at a resort for such things as select restaurants, tours, activities, spa offerings, Wi-Fi, premium alcohol and room service. Even if all of these are included, you'll likely incur extra charges for airfare, baggage fees, airport transport and resort fees.

Before booking an all-inclusive vacation, do your research to see what's included and what's not. Some resorts are more all-inclusive than others, so be sure to account for that when comparing prices.

Choosing the wrong resort

Find the right resort for you. In general, this boils down to three things: guest demographics, resort location and resort theme. Location is simple to research, and most properties are relatively clear regarding their theme. But demographics can be difficult and are usually best determined by reading reviews and looking at photos from past guests.

The resort we stayed at for a month was mainly filled with Dominican tourists and Canadians traveling on Sun Wing vacation packages, while the resort I stayed at during JetBlue's Destination Good trip promotion was more popular with large families, weddings and bachelorette parties. The other guests at the resort can have an impact on your experience, so do your research.

Traveling at the wrong time of year

We visited the Dominican Republic in the midst of hurricane season, which may have been the reason Choice priced the property at 8,000 points per night. It only rained a couple of days, but we did need to make backup plans in the form of refundable award tickets leaving the island when we were in the predicted path of a hurricane. Luckily, the storm changed course and we were able to cancel the tickets.

Also check the dates of local and national holidays, since many resorts can get crowded because they offer day passes or annual passes to local residents on those days. You may want to avoid the rainy season or humid season unless you're purposefully traveling during the offseason to get lower prices.

Related: The best destinations to visit in November

Not considering your booking options

In general, you can book direct paying cash rates, book direct using award nights or points, book using cash or points through a credit card portal or book through an online travel agent. And, as some of my recent guides have shown, no single booking method is always best. Consider all of your options.

It's also important to enter the correct number of guests when searching your options. Many all-inclusive resorts effectively charge more for each additional guest, including kids, even when you're sharing the same room. However, you can often get around this by booking award nights, as we did during our most recent stay at the Choice Ascend Hotel Collection's Emotions Puerto Plata where the cash rate almost doubled when adding a second guest but the points rate remained the same.

There are more properties than ever that you can book using hotel points. Hyatt already has a number of well-known all-inclusive properties including the Hyatt Ziva Puerto Vallarta and Hyatt Ziva Cancun . But Marriott and Choice are also adding to their all-inclusive portfolios

Not learning about resort procedures early in your stay

Each resort has intricacies that must be mastered quickly in order to take full advantage of your stay, like restaurant reservations. Some resorts let you sign up for restaurant reservations in advance or at check-in but many require you to reserve each morning for that evening. If this seems to be the case for your resort, you'll want to figure out where to make reservations, which restaurants (if any) have a surcharge and what time you can begin to make reservations each morning.

You'll also want to master the operating hours of restaurants, pools, bars and activities. Ideally, there will be a schedule of activities posted or available in your room along with a map of the resort with opening and closing times.

Not packing the right clothing

Most resorts offer a few options for dinner, ranging from a casual beach spot to a buffet to formal dining. If you plan to dine more formally, you'll want to research ahead of time what type of dress is required. The "formal" restaurants may simply require closed-toe shoes, long trousers and shirts with sleeves -- but some resorts will require significantly more formal attire.

Additionally, if you plan to leave the resort, you'll want to pay attention to local cultural norms. And of course, consider the temperature and humidity when you're packing.

Eating or drinking too much

When food and drink are included and unlimited, it can be easy to overdo it. This is especially true for the buffet restaurants, where you may keep seeing additional foods that look appetizing. I found it best to walk around the buffet to peruse the options before getting a plate.

Beer and wine may be your best bets if you plan to drink alcohol during your all-inclusive stay. These drinks have a known and consistent alcohol percentage, so you can easily track how much you are drinking. Mixed drinks, on the other hand, may get light or heavy pours depending on the bartender.

Failing to bring reusable cups

Bringing reusable cups is good for both you and the environment. Drinks at the poolside bar, swim-up bar and beach bar are usually served in small disposable plastic cups. But in pre-COVID-19 times, most all-inclusive resorts are happy to fill up your own cup, regardless of its size. I had no issue getting bartenders to fill up my water bottle with beer or rum and coke -- and I didn't need to return to the bar for refills as frequently. Of course, things may be different now, so it's best to check before you go.

Related: How to be more eco-friendly while traveling

Not packing and using sunscreen

You can usually buy sunscreen at resorts, but it may be overpriced and likely won't be your preferred brand. So if you plan to check a bag, bring ample sunscreen and use it. I saw multiple people who were painfully burned. If you're traveling alone, consider spray sunscreen or simply ask another guest to help.

Falling for a sales pitch

Many all-inclusive resorts have staff whose sole purpose is to sell timeshares, excursions, spa services and upgraded experiences. They are more aggressive at some resorts than at others but be wary that the friendly staff chatting you up shortly after check-in or by the pool may very well be trying to sell you something.

Not taking advantage of included activities and amenities

All-inclusive resorts tend to include a lot of activities and amenities you'd normally pay extra for at a normal resort. For example, room service may be complimentary, golf rounds may be included and some all-inclusive resorts even include excursions. At the same time, most all-inclusive resorts also include some premium options available for additional cost -- so it's best to determine what's included early in your stay so you can enjoy the resort to its fullest.

Not leaving the resort

It's easy to never leave an all-inclusive resort, but it's usually worth leaving to explore a nearby town, take a hike, walk around the neighborhood or have lunch at a beach cafe.

During our stay in the Dominican Republic, a taxi organization in our resort complex prohibited Ubers and other vehicles from picking up passengers. If we wanted to leave the complex, we needed to either (1) take an overpriced taxi, (2) walk 10 to 15 minutes to the resort entrance and get an Uber or (3) arrange a tour. So we walked to the entrance and requested an Uber for about a tenth of the stated price of a taxi.

Forgetting to budget for tips

Tipping is controversial, especially at all-inclusive resorts where tips may already be included. You can certainly choose not to tip and shouldn't feel obligated to tip if the all-inclusive includes tips or if tipping isn't part of the local culture. However, even if tips are included, you may want to budget some cash to acknowledge a favorite server, bartender, housekeeper or concierge.

Renting an Apartment vs. Living in an All-Inclusive Resort: You’d Be Surprised Which Is Cheaper

If you could live at an all-inclusive resort for less than your current lifestyle, would you?

Learn More: I’m a Luxury Travel Agent: 10 Destinations My Wealthy Clients Are Booking for 2024

For You: How To Get $340 Per Year in Cash Back on Gas and Other Things You Already Buy

Because for some Americans, that math actually holds true. 

Don’t believe it? Let’s dig into the numbers.

Sponsored: Owe the IRS $10K or more? Schedule a FREE consultation to see if you qualify for tax relief.

Cost of Living in the US

TikToker Ben Keenan actually ran the numbers for himself in a (now viral) video. He came up with the following monthly costs, which would disappear if he lived at an all-inclusive resort:

• Rent: $2,300
• Average Utilities: $300
• Car & Insurance: $320
• Groceries: $400
• Dinners Out: $300
• Drinks/Going Out: $300

The grand total for him came to $4,000 per month. 

Your expenses vary from his, of course — but probably not by huge margins. According to Zillow, the median rent in the US is $2,100. 

Meanwhile, the average cost to own a new car is $12,182 per year ($1,015/month), including all expenses such as insurance, repairs, maintenance, gas and so on. You might spend more or less on groceries or entertainment than Ben, but his numbers aren’t outlandish.

Cost of All-Inclusive Resorts

Like most things, pricing tends to scale based on volume. In this case, you can often pay less per night when you stay longer. 

In scrolling through all-inclusive resorts, Keenan found one in the Dominican Republic that charged $3,100 and another in Mexico charging $4,500. 

These fall within the range that many Americans pay for their combined housing, food and drink, and transportation-related costs, as outlined above. If you live at an all-inclusive resort, you don’t need a car or groceries, after all. 

Depending on your budget, you could potentially  save money by living at an all-inclusive resort.

Cost of All-Inclusive Cruises

Likewise, more stories have hit the news in recent years of adventuresome retirees and digital nomads living on cruise ships. 

The potential cost varies, of course, just like all-inclusive resorts. CruiseHive estimates between $60,000 and $150,000 per year. 

But Keenan ran the numbers combining two cruises for a total of 37 days that cost $4,042. 

The cost for both all-inclusive cruises and resorts also changes depending on how many people are going in on them. A married couple could live a cheaper per-person lifestyle than a single one, although the same is true for living in an apartment or house.

Downsides of the All-Inclusive Lifestyle

That all sounds great in theory, but what would it be like to live at an all-inclusive resort or cruise?

To begin with, you wouldn’t have much living space — especially on a cruise ship. While you wouldn’t have to live out of a suitcase, you’d still live a life with minimal personal belongings. Which might suit you just fine.

You also wouldn’t have access to a kitchen, unless you booked an extended stay suite with one. That, in turn, means you lose the option of cooking for yourself. Not everyone would mind, but it leaves you at the mercy of the food available at the resort. You might get sick of the dish rotation or may not find it healthy enough for your taste. 

Then there’s the risk of boredom. All-inclusive resorts and cruise ships are, by definition, closed spaces. While often beautiful, they offer only limited access to the wider world. The same few restaurants, bars, beaches, and amenities might lose their luster after a week or two, much less months on end.

Finally, you’d have to hop on a plane to visit friends and family back in the States. Which, of course, costs money that you don’t necessarily spend now.  

Living at an all-inclusive resort is a fun thought experiment and a great “What If.” But most Americans would probably find the reality less sexy than the idea. 

More From GOBankingRates

• 5 Japanese Cars To Stay Away From Buying
• Ramit Sethi: How To Become Rich on a Low Salary
• 5 Clever Ways to Speed Up Your Retirement Savings
• 3 Things You Must Do When Your Savings Reach $50,000

This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com : Renting an Apartment vs. Living in an All-Inclusive Resort: You’d Be Surprised Which Is Cheaper